Friday, July 28, 2006

Bettie Bloodshed's Transcipt of Tim's Podcast for Episode Three - Continued

Okay kids, you know the deal. [] is mine, () is his!!

Hi I'm Tim Gunn and this is my podcast for Episode 3...and we are calling it episode 3 because we don't know what the title is! (Laughs) So we congratulate Kayne who has won the last challenge and therefore has immunity for this episode and cannot be eliminated. Heidi announces to the designers that they will be designing an outfit inspired by fashion's hottest accessories-and that's all she is going to tell them. She adds that they will be meeting me in the morning and they will be learning more about the challenge.

So they go back to the Atlas apartments and have who knows how long a night speculating about what the fashion accessory is. Any number of things are bandied about from ipods to cellphones to...I think at one point when they see the note from me and the map and where they are going Laura starts to speculate we are doing something with horses....I don't know how hot a fashion accessory a horse is...but in any case, it is eventually revealed as I walk from behind a berm with 13 dogs on leashes. I have never been so relieved to see the designers because I am a dog lover (I have to tell you I adore them). I grew up with dogs, I love them, I can't get enough of them. But by the time the designers had arrived-I'd had enough. They were (laughs) what were they doing?! They were doing everything! Pulling out of their collars, wanting their owners who were there (but too many feet away from them), little Stanley (my adorable little Stanley) kept crying and crying and crying...we had a good time though. I do have to add that these are professional dogs! These are dogs from a professional dog agency. The owner which came with the
dogs! I was really impressed...of course...when you think about it, why wouldn't there be a professional dog agency? You don't think about those things! I will say that some of the dogs, Stanley first and foremost among them, I was surprised that they weren't a little better behaved in some ways, but it was the out of doors, there were a lot of dog walkers in the park...did I say where we went? We went to Central Park! To a beautiful setting in Central Park. I should also add that it was
freezing. Why, the last week in May [that recent?!] would be cold here in New York, I do not know, but we've had wacky weather all summer. It was really cold and the dogs were shivering and shaking despite the fact they were wearing jerseys that had their names on them.

I found out I wasn't very good at reading the names. One little dog I kept calling Lila. L-i-l-a. The owner said "no no, it's Lil' A!" Lil' A? Well, anyway it was, and it ended up being Vincent's dog. Another I thought was Felix, this adorable Corgi who wasn't responding to me because his name is Flex! ...Flex?! The material was a little wrinkled so it looked like Felix to me, but I was wrong.

So! I present the dogs to the designers, this is the accessory from which they are inspired to design. They will be creating a women's wear outfit inspired by the dog and they will also be making a corresponding outfit for the dog. It doesn't have to match necessarily, but a corresponding outfit for the dog. They have two days for the challenge and a budget of $150 each. Another part of the challenge is that they have to think narratively about the concept and about who the woman is, where is she going with the dog? What does she do? The story should be important in terms of explaining the whole context for the design. In the case of some of the designers, it was much more important than others, and not necessarily for the right reasons.

So we give them 30 minutes to measure their dogs, take photographs of the dogs, sketch, and then we are going to say Au revoir to the dogs and we are going to go shopping. I just want to mention some of the designer's reactions to the dogs. I mean, for the most part, everyone was thrilled and I thought, good, this would be a nice healing tonic for everybody to have a nice adorable pooch to pet. Here, hug the doggie and don't be upset about the last challenge.

What was so interesting and very funny was how people tended to gravitate towards dogs that resembled them. It was really true! Almost unilaterally across the board with the exception of Alison and Bradley. Bradley is there with this little prim white poodle and Alison has this -well my adorable Stanley!-kind of a shlumpy-looking terrier. Just to look at them you knew that Bradley looked much more like Stanley than Alison did and Alison looked as if she could easily own Pepito, who was
the little poodle. They decided to switch, which I thought was brilliant. Then we had Laura who was recoiling from her little dog, Sophia. She had a palpable distaste for the little thing. She carried him around in her Hermes bag. She didn't want to touch him. We had one extreme to the next. Oh! Then we had Keith, and one of the oddest looking canines I'd ever seen named Morgan. I'm not certain what the breed is, but something very very exotic. He seemed thrilled with the exoticness of it,
for he himself is rather exotic. So we have good matches all around, I thought. I was really eager to see what kind of work would develop.

What is clearly demonstrated in this episode is how truly talented the
designers really are. Many of them-most of them. We see work, the ambitions of
which have never been seen on Project Runway. We see suits with coats and jackets, so there are lots of sleeves. It is quite remarkable. Even Laura, with her very ambitions suit (which was quite stunning)...she finished early! I found her sleeping in the lounge and I was stunned! I was shocked, and I was also kind of surprised. She was taking a little cat-nap! (of course it was the dog episode..but that's what it was) So I was wowed. Really wowed.

I will also say, in the case of Alison [He means Angela-second podcast he has called her Alison at least once] we really haven't seen her design to her true vision. She was limited by materials at the Atlas apartment for the first challenge, she was Vincent's very disabled sous chef in the last challenge (that was not her design work)...so we really haven't seen who she is yet but she makes up for that. She makes up for it in full force. Hers was a case of (at least from my point of view) needing to know the narrative. Who is this woman? Who is THIS woman?! (laughs) This woman in this bubble skirt and vest and bare midriff. Well, she is an English art teacher I think she said? She is teaching at an art camp in Paris. I thought, you know, taking the art gallery to the extreme. At Parsons, for me, that is always the code for we are going to see clown clothes, a float in a parade, or moon clothes. Its going to be one of the three when she is an art gallery owner. So to be an English art teacher at an art camp in Paris?! Okay...we have the whole 9
yards-and she delivers the whole 9 yards. It was also amusing, frustrating, and interesting to see Vincent, once again, return to Hat Land [the craziest place on earth]. The Isle of Capotes. He had a fixation on this simple, black, sort of poor-boy cap he had done for his model. Then he had a little white hat for Lil' A. Lil' A had the reaction I would have had-Lil' A kept trying to get the hat off of his head. He would do everything possible. He was pushing it all over the work top of the worktable, on the floor, on the runway...we see most of this edited out
(you only need to see a little bit of it). Every time he walked the runway he was determined to get that hat off his head. It was hilarious. And I thought, "You go Lil' A! Get that hat off!" Of course, Vincent thought the hat MADE the dog outfit, MADE his model's outfit...I certainly didn't agree. In any case, he is intractable, so I have to respect him for that.

When I am touring the workroom catching up on how the designers are progressing, I have number of concerns. One is Katherine. Although her slip dress is really very beautifully done, it is really really basic. It's a slip! There is not much more to it than that. Whereas the design she has made for her adorable dog, Tallulah, is the real Katherine, in my opinion. It's this sporty little hoodie-it's adorable. Though probing, I hope, I got her to say that she would make a corresponding hoodie for the model. I said, bravo, do it! It didn't get done (it was a matter of time more than anything else). We should have woken Laura up and had her do the hoodie!

Bradley. I...well I'm the same way now...I was sort of speechless. First I was perplexed about the fabrics he bought, and specifically the colors. This purple wools skirt, this gold, silk I believe, for the top...I just thought, this is really a commitment. This is it. And its all going to sit in these fabrics (as it would for anybody) but it was just so powerful. How was he going to make that work? At the time I saw the top-the top was an exercise in deconstruction. It was fraying
everywhere and when I asked him about it he said he wanted it to look like Stanley. I just thought, this is gold silk...isn't that contradictory to what the material wants to do...and its not attractive! It's not pretty. My advice was to clean it up, and clean it up considerably. But it also was a big floppy kinda mess. Well you could say that is also like Stanley, but we don't want that top to look like a dog. Trust me, you don't.

Then there was Keith who had a stunning design. I loved his fabric, I loved the innovative way he worked the halter into a pleated collar that echoed the pleats in the skirt, but he had no intention of doing anything for his exotic dog Morgan. No intention at all. I said its part of the challenge! You are going to be evaluated on this. If there is nothing there, you are going to...self forfeit, in a way! He
was...quite...petulant about it. "The dog is exotic enough, it is great and grand
enough...I don't need to do this! Period." It was like he was saying, I'm bigger and better than this challenge and its rules [ruuules? Breaking rules? Hmmm], so screw you. Well, I thought, okay, we'll see what the judges have to say.

There was a lot of stunning work in the room. Alison-incredible. Uli, well let me come back to Uli. Kayne's incredible ambitious work was a beautiful dress and this crocodile embossed black vinyl coat he was making...I remember being flabbergasted-I still am! You are making this coat? And he was lining it with the fabric from the dress. It was incredibly ambitions and incredibly beautiful.

Laura's design was exquisite. Jeffrey's at this point I couldn't quite wrap my brain around. Jeffrey finishes, but boy is it a close call. It's a real close call. I'm wringing my hands at the 11th hour yet again.

Back to Uli. When I saw her shopping for that fabric at mood and I saw her buying these two completely (contradictory is an understatement) challenging fabrics. One print I thought was Pucci's view of the cosmos. It's like a moon and the planets and the solar system. Then she had this giraffe print, and I thought...what?! But she is incredible when it comes to working a print. She is incredible. In fact, I ended up saying the only other person who could touch these and make them work as well as you is Diane Von Furstenberg, who is the master of the print. The grand master. She completely blew me away. She also had a jacket, this beautiful coffee colored linen cropped jacket that was adorable. Her little pug, Einstein (laughs)...she said, another German! Einstein was adorable and she used the giraffe print to make a little coat for him that said "hi ladies" Hi ladies, what?! It's for the judges! (laughs) It was adorable.

I felt, with the exception of Jeffery and his maybe not finishing, the person I was just despondent over was Bradley. The morning of the judging I just said, this is just awful. It was also his birthday! And what I didn't know was that he was really resigned to not showing at all-and I said no. That cannot happen. You are going to go out there with something, no matter what it is. And I meant it. There was no way he wasn't-something was going down that runway if I had to send it down! He was really...I don't know what happened to him. He was in a state. It
concerned me enormously, and I care about him. [Aww...is Bradley going to become the next Andrae in Tim's heart?] I care about all of them, but he was the one who was the neediest at this point.

In terms of Katherine and the slip dress, and Tallulah...well, at least it was beautifully constructed. I was worried about how basic it was, but it was beautifully made.

It was funny though, when Bradley's walked the runway, I thought, its Daniel V's Orchid dress from the season two inspiration challenge. And in a way, it really was. The slim fitting skirt, the voluminous top...and I thought, well maybe the judges won't know how much he struggled. And in fact, Nina loved it. I mean, she really responded well to it. I think she even said something, "I would publish that in Elle!" I thought, "Well, whew, I'm relieved it was on the runway and you like it, but you'd publish it in Elle?" Well, anyways...that's her business.

The runway was superb, I thought. It was really excellent and honestly, I didn't have a clue who would be out. Once the judges selected the best and the worst it was a little clearer where they were going with things. But I really thought that this could go anywhere. It's a matter of taste. I think this will become my podcast refrain, "it's a matter of taste, it's a matter of taste."

So I was really proud of all of them. I will say we had some backstage noise. Who was it from? Stanley! Crying, whining...poor little thing. We had to stop taping at one point, he was so loud. You know you sorta wanted to go back their and hug him-or slap him! (laughs) But he missed his owner, I suppose. But the dogs, other than Stanley, were superbly behaved. There are several hours of runway and walking and deliberations-they didn't have to 'do' a thing. There wasn't a single accident. Those are professional dogs for you!

In the category of best and worst we have the best as Uli and Allison, and in the worse we have Katherine and Angela. Then we have an ambiguous category with Bradley and Keith. It's ambiguous because some judges responded well to Bradley, others didn't. With Keith it was unanimous that the dress was beautiful but it was the issue with the dog. And it was a BIG issue because Keith had pulled (I thought it was a belt but I was very wrong) a bracelet from the accessory wall and simply put it on Morgan. I guess it was his last ditch effort to do something for the dog. But then he tried to pass it off as his own work. He even went so far to say he designed three or four outfits for the dog and he decided not to use them and that less was more. I thought...talk about a bunch of bull**** [He is not happy at this point tonal wise]. I never saw them! You could see the designers looking at each other and rolling their eyes and saying oh boy...

So Heidi actually gets up from her judging seat and declares,
"J'accuse!!! That collar that you designed is from the Macy's accessory wall! I
recognize it!"Then he said that he put a little sash on it that I made..
WHAT?! It was unbelievable and unmitigated hubris. I just couldn't
believe that he had the audacity to represent things that way. But he did...boy did he. ....enough already. I'll stop.

So Bradley gets through and I'm thinking hurray! Big happy birthday! Bravo Stanley too, you can go home now. Not Bradley, but Stanley. Keith leaves the runway, Alison is lauded for her excellent work and she leaves. Oh and the little leather vest she did for little Pepito was just wonderful.

So we have Angela and Katherine. Well I don't know how everybody at home felt, but Angela's was ridiculous looking. Who is this client...her twin?! She was dressed exactly the same way! She could have just put on a robe and given her own clothes to her model. Bubble skirts covered in these crafty floweret's...oh! I was reminded of being a kid and using face tissues to make little roses and things. You are 5 years old and putting them on a craft project. Fashion designers shouldn't go there. So we have this baroque bubble skirt and this revealing vest for someone running a kids camp? I mean...I dunno. If we were training for the Follies that would be one thing-but art? ...anyway. I felt that her responses to the judges were vague and insubstantial in their own way. At least Katherine's work was believable. It wasn't a costume. But it was really, really basic. I will say that among the designers, she is the youngest and has the least amount of experience and in terms of design, I was reminded of the situation with Santino. At least Angela's was
something you could talk about. There wasn't much to say about Katherine's. Consequently, she was the designer who was voted out.

So Uli wins with that beautiful garment. She took a lot of risk with that. It could have been a big hot horrible mess. I mean, it really could have been. It could have looked like someone regurgitated pizza or something, but she really pulled it off and walked a very fine line of 'will it succeed or will it fail?' And boy, did it succeed! I was thrilled for her and thrilled for little Einstein, who was adorable. I also loved the 'hi ladies' part, which the judges liked too-but it didn't sway them that much, if it swayed them at all. It was just an arresting
little addition. Bravo! Bravo, Uli!

I want to add that our guest judge for this challenge was Ivanka Trump and there is not enough time to extol all of her praises. She was incredible. She is not only extremely intelligent and articulate, she knows her fashion inside and out. I don't mean shallow, oh I shop a lot fashion. She knows her designers, her historic references...she knows how to critique a garment incredibly well, and I only hope we have her back again. She was fantastic, and we all thank her. Thank you Ivanka!!

So in our next challenge we send the designers into the real world.
The world of retail and the challenge is big.


Click here to comment.