Wednesday, September 13, 2006
Transcript of Tim's Podcast - "Couture du Jour" continued
So Catherine’s not only our guest judge, she’s really kind of our host in Paris. She introduces the next challenge, which is all about couture. Paris is undeniably the couture capital, because it can’t happen anywhere else. I just want to bore everybody with a few words about couture because it’s a term that’s bantered about frequently, and it’s misused more frequently than not. I misuse it in my own way. I do it with the students: “Oh, you mean couture-like.” “Couture-like” is a perfectly appropriate term. It’s fine to use it, but the actual word “couture,” to say someone’s a couture designer… To be a couture designer, you have to be voted into office, so to speak, by the French government, by the Chambre Syndicale de something-or-other. It’s a really important distinction. I used to say that Ralph Rucci was the only American couture designer when we were in Paris. I found out I was wrong—he’s not knighted by the Chambre Syndicale. He is invited as a guest to show during the couture shows. So they have not bestowed this couture title to him. He does show during that period of time, but he’s not a couture designer. So, aside from all of the particulars that go into a couture dress or suit or gown, that designation by the French government is or isn’t in place. And it must be in place, or you’re not a couture designer. There are only seven of them right now. I read a very interesting statistic—I think it comes from the 1930s, so it was before World War II—there were a shockingly large number of couture houses—something like 300. Three hundred? I couldn’t name 30 if I had to! It was astounding. But the numbers keep getting smaller and smaller and smaller. Part of it is because of the cost of supporting a couture house. They certainly don’t do it off the couture. There are maybe—I don’t know—six, seven, eight ladies who buy couture, and that’s about it. So couture makes a big, splashing statement on the runway, and then it trickles down to ready-to-wear. So it’s the ready-to-wear, it’s the accessories, it’s the fragrances—those things make the money for the couture houses, not the couture collections. Because today, a couture dress—$60,000, $100,000 is pretty commonplace. And how do you make money off of that? I mean, it’s probably six to eight people, taking hundreds of hours to create a single dress. It’s really a daunting thing to try to wrap your brain around. But that’s… I just wanted to go off on a brief tangent to just talk about what it really is.
So, we are—our designers are designing a dress that will have couture elements in it. The most basic thing to describe when it comes to a couture element—what is it—is hand sewing. Beading is another couture element… embroidery, embellishments… but they all have to be hand done. You can’t bring a machine into this, or it doesn’t count any longer—it’s disqualified. So, they have two days to create this couture garment—or couture-like, excuse me—couture-like garment. They have a budget of 300 euros, which is about 375 American dollars. That’s a pretty generous budget for us on Project Runway. But we’re going shopping in Paris. It’s undoubtedly going to be more expensive than most things that we find at Mood. We just want to make certain that the designers aren’t handicapped in any way by not having an appropriate budget.
So, we also learn from Catherine that she’s going to host a party where these couture designs—couture-like designs—will be showcased. We don’t know any more than that until later, of course. So the designers are very excited about that.
I cannot adequately describe how warm and lovely and incredible Catherine Malandrino is. She’s just great, and she has the patience of a saint. I may have mentioned in our last podcast that our plane was delayed. We were late arriving at Parsons Paris. She had been there waiting for us for three or four hours or more. Paris was so hot, and air conditioning is a rare thing in Paris. When we got there, of course we had to set up the lights and the cameras and get the room ready, and it took a long time. Owing to our wanting to position the cameras in different places—and we had a limited crew because we traveled—we had to do a couple of things twice so that we could get different camera angles. She couldn’t have been lovelier. She was wonderful. There had been some boohooing about the fact that we didn’t have Jean Paul Gautier specifically, because we had talked to him, and he had initially agreed to do it, then he had a conflict. I kept thinking, “Well, Gautier wouldn’t have been here waiting for us.” But Catherine Malandrino was, and she was incredible.
So, the designers and I go back to the hotel and freshen up because we’ve had two long days with travel in the middle. I’m taking them out to dinner. We have an incredible evening walk across the Seine, and through the courtyard of the Louvre, and near the Palais Royale. We end up having just a wonderful, wonderful outdoor dinner. It couldn’t be lovelier. It couldn’t be nicer.
Have I ever mentioned any of the designers’ food foibles? I don’t know that I have. Well, Vincent has one. Surprise! Now I can’t remember what it is. I mean, I have a category of it—it’s either he’s a vegetarian and/or he’s a vegan. So [laughs] we’re ordering dinner… There had been calls placed to the restaurant in advance about the fact that we have a special dietary need. The restaurant, being gracious and elegant, is prepared for that. Well, Vincent doesn’t want it. He wants to order off the menu. I said to him “What?? What are you going to order off this menu?” He’s going to have the lamb. “The lamb?! What are you talking about you’re going to have lamb?! You told me that this regimen of yours is like a religion and that you couldn’t stray from it, and now you’re going to have lamb?!” And he had one response. He looked at me and said, “When in Rome.” I was flabbergasted. I was totally flabbergasted. I thought, “Maybe we left Vincent on the plane, and this was a pod.” I don’t know. Anyway. Vincent had lamb.
We had a lovely night, and we walked back to the hotel, and the hotel was magnificent. I love traveling with Project Runway. We go to places I couldn’t possibly go on my own. No, it was great.
So, the next day, we want to use the city as inspiration for the design. It’s a way for getting us out in the city. We go way up to Montmartre, which happens to also be where all the great fabric stores are. We go to the Sacré Coeur, which has the most incredible view out over the city. I apologize for my French accent. The day is crystal clear and sparkling. It’s hot as hell, [laughs] but it’s crystal clear, it’s sparkling. The designers are in a park in front of the Sacré Coeur. They’re sketching and really having a great time. I’m trying to keep from having sunstroke, and I’m pretty successful at it.
We go to a fabric store called “Rain” or “Reine” [rhymes with “men”]. I think it’s really pronounced “Reine.” I think I say “Rain” on the show because someone told me to. It is incredibly organized and chock-a-block with everything. I didn’t know what to expect really, but I was thinking that the whole Paris setup would be more like New York: that you’d have fabric stores, notions stores… that there’d be this demarcation between them. But no, this was one-stop shopping. It was phenomenal. The designers were busy busy, busy at work, investigating what was there and getting a handle on it.
And… [laughs] again, poor Vincent. I’m sorry, Vincent. I was standing next to our producer, Rich Bye, watching our designers run around, watching them look at the fabric. I had been looking at the fabric too. As I was talking to Rich, I was still looking at the fabric, and [chuckles] I picked up the end of the bolt of this horrible fabric—I mean, it was like some bad upholstery fabric from some maiden aunt who lives in a cave. I just looked at Rich and I said, “Who would ever choose this? And for what?” Guess who choose it! Yes, he did. Actually, it looked better in the workroom than it did at the fabric store, but still, it looked like a couch.
So, I leave the designers alone. They’re busy at work. I return later that night, and I’m concerned about a number of people. I am very concerned about Kayne. He is using a gold mesh fabric for the top—but very structured, boned top—corset-like. And the boning fits into the whole couture-like challenge. I believe. I’m with him. I subscribe. I get it. However, the boning was black, so you could see all of it. I kept saying, “Don’t you want this to go away?” And he said, “I’m going to cover it with the mesh.” So I said, “Well, let’s do it. let’s put the mesh over it.” As I’m going away, it’s still there. You can see it. “Don’t you want it to go away?” “Well, it’s black. what am I going to do? I can’t take it back.” This is when… I’m not supposed to tell them what to do. It’s sort of like I’m gesturing with my elbow… like, you know, “Nude fabric over here, Kayne!” I’m gesturing and using a little eye twitch. He wasn’t getting it. Because, of course, I can’t say those words, but it was like, “Kayne, just look at what’s on the table. There’s a solution here.” And I walked away.
So, the other person who was concerning me was Michael. And the concern evolved. It evolved from an initial concern because he seemed… He seemed sort of disabled by the couture-like aspect of this, and I couldn’t fathom why. He’s brilliant. He’s brilliant as a designer. He’s brilliant as a person. He’s thoughtful as a designer. I couldn’t understand why he was so disabled—that’s the word I’ll use. So I tried to prop him up and pep him up and say, “You know, this really shouldn’t be any different from anything else you’ve designed. You’re going to have to hand sew something—that’s the difference—‘couture-like.’ It’s not… We don’t want a Galliano float in a parade. We want you. The judges want to see you, so this shouldn’t be debilitating. Don’t let it be.” And I left him.
Vincent, I left alone.
Uli seemed fine. She was working away like the busy German bee that she is. [laughs]
Jeffrey. Well, first of all, I think he was really buoyed up by his win. And he had immunity, so there was no way he was going to go home. I looked at the fabrics he was selecting, and I thought, “Is he pulling a Santino?” I remember from Season Two, Santino saying something about, “Well, I wish I had immunity for X because I’d design something that would cause the judges to go run in front of traffic.” Santino, you did it anyway, even without immunity. I thought, “Is this what Jeffrey’s doing?” He was picking all of these different tartans and plaids, and they were yellow to boot. I mean, yellow is a difficult fashion color for anybody, and then these yellow tartans and plaids? It was sort of like what Uli does with a print, but Uli is a master of print. I didn’t have a lot of confidence in what I projected Jeffrey could do with this. So, I looked at him at Reine, and he looked at me, and I just blurted out, “Vivian Westwood?” (question mark). He laughed and said, “Yeah.” And I said, “Alright, but his could become a joke, and I don’t think you want to go there, do you?” He said “No, it’s not going to be a joke.” “Alright. Well, let’s see.” And he had the guts to purchase it.
So, back in the workroom at Parsons Paris I was—I won’t say I was dubious, but I was watchful. I thought, “Where is this going? Where is this really going, and how is he really going to use this?” I mean, I’m learning more and more about the designers the more time we spend together. Jeffrey seems to be more about draping and less about a pattern, even though he does excellent menswear design, which is really only about patterns—well, I shouldn’t say that—but largely about patterns, anyway. I was watchful. As I think about it now, I think I feel more dubious now than I did then. But it was… there was just a lot of “look.” That’s what I’ll say—there was a lot of “look.”
I love Laura, but Laura had a Laura dress… Morticia Addams. She had a basic, black, Morticia Addams dress. And… “OK, Laura, what’s going to be couture about this?” And she talked me through it. She was going to do this collar, feathered collar, I believe out of organza, and cuffs. And I could see the collar; I was worried about the cuffs. She wasn’t; I was. And would they just be too much? But then, it was, you know, couture-like, so I was placated and I left her alone.
So, day two. Back in the workroom, I’m more worried about Michael. He’s building up this midriff corset-y thing. And it’s looking a lot like what Malan and Katherine did for Miss USA. And it’s concerning me. I mean, Michael hasn’t had a misstep. He hasn’t. And I just talked to him about it very bluntly. “Help. Do something about this.” And it was very ambitious in its own way, but it wasn’t particularly pretty. So my concerns were escalating.
Laura. Laura was sort of flirting—I think that’s the term I’ll use—flirting with the look of, is the term, this collar. And I told her, “You know, it’s got to really be exuberant. It has to go over the top. This is everything. This is the only opportunity you have to make a statement about what’s couture-like, and you really need to sell it.” So she said, “I will. I’ll go to work. I’ll go to work.” And she was also really tired. I think the trip did her in, in a way. I mean, she’s three months pregnant, but she’s a trooper. An incredible trooper.
I was more worried about Kayne. What I thought was at least going to be a symmetrical top was now asymmetrical. I said, “But your whole skirt’s asymmetrical. This is really going way too far, and there’s a taste issue here too. You’ve got to rein some of this in, or at least I’m suggesting you rein some of it in.” He was listening to me, I do know that, but I don’t know that he knew how to get out of it. And the boning was still very much in evidence. He said he liked it. “Alright.” I said, “OK, I’ll accept it. Let me now bring in the point of view of the judges. The judges ask you, ‘Kayne, why are we looking at the boning?’ Is it adequate for you to say, ‘I like it’?” Because, generally speaking, that’s an infrastructure. You want it to go away. It’s like saying, “Kayne, I can see the model’s underpants.” “Well, that’s alright. I like it.” Well, if it were Vincent, “That’s OK. it makes me hot.” I don’t know what to say.
Uli. Fantastic. Wonderful. I mean, she’s doing an Uli dress, but she’s really taking it—well, I won’t say she’s taking it over the top—she’s making it extremely elegant. Most of her work, though it can be floor length and cut like an evening gown, it reads like sportswear. This didn’t. This really read like a beautiful evening gown. Now, that wasn’t the challenge. It didn’t have to be. Now, again, “couture-like” was the only criterion. It could have been a suit for a lady who lunches. But in this case it was an evening dress, and it was becoming a knockout. Really a knockout.
Vincent. Well, I kept repeating to Vincent—I know I was annoying him and that was not my intention. My intention was merely to get him to respond to my question, which he was not. My question was, “What is couture-like about this dress?” It was the middle of the afternoon the second day, and there was still nothing couture-like about it. He said to me, pointing to the hem, “I’m going to hand sew the hem.” Under the circumstances of the time constraint and him, I simply said, “Fine, hand sew the hem. At least you can say with impunity ‘I did hand sewing,’ and you did. You did the hem. OK, fine.” I leave him.
I go to Jeffrey, and all that I can say is that it looked like a cyclone had moved into his workspace. Fabrics everywhere. The dress form looks like it’s been struck by lightning. All that I could really say was, “I hope you know what you’re doing because I don’t.” He was really confident. Really confident. And I said, “OK, fine then.” Then I turn around, and I’m really turning around to leave the room, and what am I struck by? Vincent’s standing there with a bottle of glue! Glue! He is gluing the hem of the dress! And I just said, “Since when did glue become a couture technique?! I don’t understand this! And, from where I sit, you have plenty of time!” He said something to me like, “Well, you don’t know what’s in my schedule” [laughs] or something. “I don’t know what’s in your schedule? Well, you’re going to be here until midnight tonight, and we’ll have some time tomorrow before the runway judging. But… what do you mean I don’t know what’s in your schedule?” I was a little baffled. But he has voices in his head that speak to him and to whom he speaks.
So, we had two days for this challenge. The night of the second day was Catherine’s party. We get into our Paris version of the Project Runway van—the Paris cousin of the van in New York. We head off to the outskirts of Paris, and we head to the river, to the Seine. The designers don’t know where we’re going. Since the river is so much a part of Paris, nobody ever thinks, “Well, we’re going to the river.” And… we are going to the river. We’re getting on a bateau mouche, a big, long, flat boat, and we’re going to take a ride, and it’s going to be incredible. We’re going to have a cocktail party on the boat. So we’re walking from the van to the bateau mouche, and there’s a large apartment building across the street. And an egg is thrown at us. It hits the pavement and ricochets up on Michael’s dress, the dress on his model. I was horrified. I mean, I was really, really horrified. I didn’t scream, “Run!” But I did something close to that and just wanted to get all the designers out of the way and thought, “Are more eggs following?” We didn’t know. Fortunately, it was only one, but it did its damage. It was really not nice, and I can only assume that it was some Parisian brat that threw it. “Take that, Parisian brat!” We were able to clean up Michael’s dress. Had it become an issue in the judging we would have simply said, “Do not blame poor Michael. It was not his fault.”
So, we arrive on the boat. We were graciously greeted by Catherine, who, I will tell you… She was really blown away. She was really blown away, as was I. I felt like a proud dad. She loved the dresses and couldn’t believe that they had executed them in this incredibly short amount of time. I mean, later, under scrutiny, she had her issues, but she was really blown away.
So, we have our runway show. Catherine has our judging cards, and she’s taking all of her notes. She and I were standing together, and I want to assure everyone I was not influencing her in any way… but I was simply someone to whom she could speak to… and, and… I offered her as little response as possible usually… And generally she wanted to know, “Can I really honest and direct?” “Yeah.” And she was. And we saw evidence of that when she was judging the work after we got off the plane. I mean, she was very direct, and it’s one of the things I love about her.
Oh, and I also want to add something. I don’t think it’s in the show, and I’m sorry that it isn’t. It’s probably my pronunciation, which is so horrible. I asked Isabelle LeBlanc, who’s a longstanding friend of mine, and she’s associated with Parsons Paris. I’ve known Isabelle for 23 years. I asked her, “Isabelle, how do you say, ‘make it work’”—because “make it work” is really idiomatic— “How do you say ‘make it work in French?” And she said, “Gee, let me think about this,” because it is an idiom. So she said, “Débrouillez-vous.” So I was running around saying—I guess it was annoying to the producers—“Débrouillez-vous, everyone!” [laughs] We also got “carry on,” but I can’t remember what that was because I don’t think I ever used it. I think it sounded too silly, not that carry on doesn’t! But, at any rate, I did my best to do, as Vincent says, “when in Rome!” [laughs] Oh god, he’s too much!
So, we bid “au revoir” to Paris, and we get back on the plane. Delta, once again, couldn’t be more wonderful to us. They were just great. We returned first class. Oh, it was fantastic. I kept saying, “Can’t I just stay on the plane? It’s so much nicer than my apartment.”
And we have our runway judging again in New York. Richard Tyler is our guest judge, and you may recall from our last podcast, Richard Tyler is the one who redesigned all of the uniforms for Delta. And Michael, of course, and Nina and, of course, we can’t do anything without Heidi, who we really missed. I wish Heidi had been with us for the trip. She would have had a great time too.
So, the last four standing—the two best and the two worst. Well, the two best are Jeffrey and Uli. And I have to say Jeffrey really pulled it out. He did a phenomenal job. And it really worked. It really did. But, you know, it’s the kind of garment if you saw it on a hanger you wouldn’t understand it. You wouldn’t get it at all. It looks like a bunch of fabric and sort of a riotous cacophony of fabric at that. But this really, really worked on the model. You believed when you saw it. Uli, as you already know from what I’ve said—stunning, great, beautiful.
And who are the two who are on the runway for having the lowest scores? Well, there’re three people. There’s Michael, there’s Laura, and there’s Vincent. I was really surprised by Laura’s… by Laura being there. I have to say, in the end… well, you know, it’s that whole “matter of taste” thing—I simply don’t have it. No, I shouldn’t say that—I do have taste. It was… I thought it was beautiful. The judges didn’t agree. They didn’t like it. They thought it was “old looking.” And you know, the only way that I could see its being “old looking” was, you could picture a more mature woman wearing it. Well, I like that aspect of it. I could see someone young wearing it, but I could see, frankly, someone 75 years old wearing it and, with the right figure, looking great.
Michael. I just have to say… I said to myself, “The judges will have to forgive him for this. This was a misstep. He just stumbled, but it was the only time he’s ever stumbled.” And I just thought, “He can’t be out. It’s not going to happen. It can’t. It can’t happen.” In fact, I’d probably throw myself across the doorway to keep it from happening. “Michael, you’re not leaving. I don’t care.” That’s when I go back in the workroom [and say] “You’re not cleaning up your space. You’re going back upstairs, and you’re doing the next challenge.”
But in fact, the one who was out was Vincent. Glue aside, it was an OK dress. It was, you know… It wasn’t the greatest thing in the world, but again, at this point, with the designers we have left, where we are with the challenges, there’s not going to be some horror . The designers are good, and his simply was the one they liked the least. It’s that simple. I was annoyed by the glue though, so I will go back to that. And part of why—I’m repeating myself, but—part of why I was annoyed and still am is that he had time to do some hand sewing. Why didn’t he? Furthermore, there were problems with the hem. So once the hem was glued, there was no way it was going to come apart again. I mean, not without some damage to the fabric and some pushing and stretching, so it was a problem.
And Laura… I just felt so bad for her. And in fact, in some ways I felt like I’d betrayed her for not preparing her for the possibility that she could be one of the ones with the lowest votes. Though I do know that in the workroom, other designers had said to her, “Horrible. I don’t like this.” But then, they’ve said that many times about her, so I thought, “Well…” And I’m constantly reminding her that, though she is more than 10 years younger than I am—11 to be precise—I keep reminding her that she and I are the old farts, so what would we know? [laughs]
Alright, so… Vincent is out, and as far as I was concerned that’s the way it should have gone. And Jeffrey wins, and for him it’s another… it’s a second win in a row… it’s like Michael. And I was… I have to tell you I was really thrilled. I was really thrilled. I mean, I loved what Uli did. I loved it. It only surprised me in that it reached an elegant height that I hadn’t seen from her. And I loved that, but it was definitely an Uli dress—and I mean that in the most wonderful way. Jeffrey really surprised me. And I think… Because of the huge elements of risking-taking here, and because it could have been a big, giant flop, I really applauded it and was thrilled—thrilled—that the judges recognized that too. I’m thrilled for him. So, congratulations Jeffrey.
Alright… we’re back from Paris we’re back in New York. We’re going to stay in New York, I’ll tell you that. And next week [laughs] we have a big surprise!